Skip to content

LD 942

Neutral Icon

LD 942

Good Science

An Act to Create Guidelines to Promote Good Science in Rulemaking

Session
2004
Status

This sneaky bill sounded reasonable, but was really intended to slow the process by which laws are enforced, and perhaps open rules to litigation. Maine’s rulemaking process is already a slow and deliberate one that allows significant public input and requires agencies to explain the basis for the rule. If rules are substantive, they have to be approved by the Maine Legislature. LD #942 required state agencies to provide upon request a list of the “primary sources” of information used in reaching a decision. That would have imposed added paperwork to understaffed agencies, and created a tool to slow the process further – a tool that only insiders would know about.

House 39 87 19 | 145 total

Herbert C. Adams
District 33, D
Pro Environment Vote
Mary Black Andrews
District 2, R
Anti Environment Vote
James D. Annis
District 112, R
Anti Environment Vote
Walter E. Ash, Jr.
District 105, D
Pro Environment Vote
Susan M.W. Austin
District 41, R
Anti Environment Vote
Christopher R. Barstow
District 23, D
Pro Environment Vote
Stephen R. Beaudette
District 18, D
Pro Environment Vote
Philip R. Bennett, Jr.
District 147, D
Pro Environment Vote
Robert A. Berube
District 84, R
Anti Environment Vote
Leonard Earl Bierman
District 132, R
Absent
Patricia A. Blanchette
District 119, D
Anti Environment Vote
Lawrence S. Bliss
District 24, D
Anti Environment Vote
Stephen Bowen
District 63, R
Anti Environment Vote
David E. Bowles
District 9, R
Anti Environment Vote
Joseph C. Brannigan
District 35, D
Anti Environment Vote
Bonita J. Breault
District 14, D
Absent
Richard B. Brown
District 4, R
Anti Environment Vote
William P. Browne
District 94, R
Anti Environment Vote
Joseph Bruno
District 38, R
Anti Environment Vote
Joan Bryant-Deschenes
District 75, R
Anti Environment Vote
Thomas D. Bull
District 48, D
Pro Environment Vote
George H. Bunker, Jr.
District 136, D
Pro Environment Vote
James J. Campbell, Sr.
District 11,
Anti Environment Vote
Marilyn E. Canavan
District 99, D
Pro Environment Vote
Roderick W. Carr
District 138, R
Absent
John W. Churchill
District 146, R
Anti Environment Vote
Eugene L. Churchill
District 128, R
Anti Environment Vote
Joseph E. Clark
District 140, D
Pro Environment Vote
Harold A. Clough
District 22, R
Anti Environment Vote
Ronald F. Collins
District 7, R
Anti Environment Vote
Patrick Colwell
District 91, D
Anti Environment Vote
Jonathan T.E. Courtney
District 6, R
Anti Environment Vote
Scott W. Cowger
District 92, D
Absent
Margaret M. Craven
District 88, D
Pro Environment Vote
Philip A. Cressey, Jr.
District 47, R
Anti Environment Vote
Robert H. Crosthwaite
District 127, R
Anti Environment Vote
Glenn A. Cummings
District 37, D
Anti Environment Vote
Darlene J. Curley
District 21, R
Anti Environment Vote
Robert A. Daigle
District 13, R
Anti Environment Vote
Gerald M. Davis
District 40, R
Anti Environment Vote
Benjamin F. Dudley
District 30, D
Pro Environment Vote
Edward R. Dugay
District 131, D
Absent
Matthew Dunlap
District 121, D
Pro Environment Vote
Robert W. Duplessie
District 29, D
Anti Environment Vote
Guy J. Duprey, Jr.
District 139, D
Pro Environment Vote
Brian M. Duprey
District 114, R
Anti Environment Vote
William M. Earle
District 56, D
Anti Environment Vote
Sean Faircloth
District 117, D
Pro Environment Vote
Edward D. Finch
District 101, D
Anti Environment Vote
Jeremy R. Fischer
District 145, D
Anti Environment Vote
Kenneth C. Fletcher
District 102, R
Anti Environment Vote
Rosita Gagne-Friel
District 69, D
Pro Environment Vote
Stanley J. Gerzofsky
District 50, D
Pro Environment Vote
Kevin J. Glynn
District 27, R
Anti Environment Vote
Albion D. Goodwin
District 134, D
Pro Environment Vote
Christian D. Greeley
District 122, R
Absent
Carol A. Grose
District 55, D
Anti Environment Vote
Paul R. Hatch
District 98, D
Anti Environment Vote
Theodore H. Heidrich
District 64, R
Anti Environment Vote
Kenneth A. Honey
District 58, R
Anti Environment Vote
Randy E. Hotham
District 67, R
Anti Environment Vote
Deborah J. Hutton
District 53, D
Pro Environment Vote
Troy Dale Jackson
District 151, D
Anti Environment Vote
Lawrence E. Jacobsen
District 12, R
Anti Environment Vote
Rodney C. Jennings
District 93, D
Pro Environment Vote
Arlan R. Jodrey
District 65, R
Anti Environment Vote
Henry L. Joy
District 141, R
Anti Environment Vote
Jeffrey H. Kaelin
District 107, R
Absent
Susanne P. Ketterer
District 97, D
Pro Environment Vote
Theodore S. Koffman
District 130, D
Pro Environment Vote
Mary Ellen Ledwin
District 116, R
Anti Environment Vote
David G. Lemoine
District 20, D
Anti Environment Vote
Paul J. Lessard
District 52, D
Anti Environment Vote
Sarah O. Lewin
District 3, R
Anti Environment Vote
Jacqueline A. Lundeen
District 144, D
Anti Environment Vote
Louis B. Maietta
District 26, R
Absent
Richard H. Mailhot
District 86, D
Anti Environment Vote
Elaine C. Makas
District 90, D
Pro Environment Vote
Boyd P. Marley
District 36, D
Pro Environment Vote
Lisa T. Marrache
District 100, D
Absent
Earle L. McCormick
District 82, R
Anti Environment Vote
Monica McGlocklin
District 66, D
Pro Environment Vote
Bernard E. McGowan
District 104, D
Absent
Linda Rogers McKee
District 79, D
Pro Environment Vote
Terrence P. McKenney
District 42, R
Anti Environment Vote
Janet L. McLaughlin
District 25, D
Anti Environment Vote
Deborah K. McNeil
District 62, R
Absent
H. Sawin Millett, Jr.
District 68, R
Anti Environment Vote
S. Peter Mills
District 108, R
Anti Environment Vote
Janet T. Mills
District 78, D
Absent
Stanley A. Moody
District 80, D
Anti Environment Vote
Gary W. Moore
District 43, R
Anti Environment Vote
Thomas W. Murphy, Jr.
District 8, R
Anti Environment Vote
Kevin M. Muse
District 45, R
Anti Environment Vote
William S. Norbert
District 34, D
Pro Environment Vote
Jacqueline R. Norton
District 120, D
Pro Environment Vote
Robert W. Nutting
District 103, R
Anti Environment Vote
Lillian LaFontaine O'Brien
District 89, D
Pro Environment Vote
Julie Ann O'Brien
District 96, R
Anti Environment Vote
Christopher P. O'Neil
District 15, D
Anti Environment Vote
Rosaire Paradis, Jr.
District 150, D
Pro Environment Vote
John L. Patrick
District 70, D
Anti Environment Vote
Anita Peavey Haskell
District 137, R
Absent
Edward Pellon
District 133, D
Anti Environment Vote
Leila J. Percy
District 51, D
Pro Environment Vote
Joseph C. Perry, Sr.
District 118, D
Absent
Anne C. Perry
District 135, D
Anti Environment Vote
Raymond G. Pineau
District 76, D
Pro Environment Vote
Hannah M. Pingree
District 129, D
Pro Environment Vote
John F. Piotti
District 110, D
Pro Environment Vote
Christopher W. Rector
District 61, R
Anti Environment Vote
Maitland E. Richardson
District 81, R
Anti Environment Vote
John G. Richardson, Jr.
District 49, D
Anti Environment Vote
Earl E. Richardson
District 111, R
Anti Environment Vote
Peter L. Rines
District 57, D
Absent
William T. Rogers, Jr.
District 115, R
Anti Environment Vote
Richard W. Rosen
District 113, R
Anti Environment Vote
Sonya G. Sampson
District 74, D
Absent
Thomas B. Saviello
District 77, R
Anti Environment Vote
Roger L. Sherman
District 142, R
Anti Environment Vote
Thomas F. Shields
District 72, R
Anti Environment Vote
Deborah L. Simpson
District 73, D
Pro Environment Vote
William J. Smith
District 149, D
Absent
Nancy E. Smith
District 83, D
Anti Environment Vote
Lois A. Snowe-Mello
District 71, R
Anti Environment Vote
Oscar C. Stone
District 5, R
Anti Environment Vote
Gary E. Sukeforth
District 60,
Anti Environment Vote
Nancy B. Sullivan
District 17, D
Absent
Edward J. Suslovic
District 32, D
Pro Environment Vote
Richard M. Sykes
District 46, R
Anti Environment Vote
Joshua A. Tardy
District 125, R
Anti Environment Vote
Jonathan Thomas
District 123, D
Pro Environment Vote
Judd D. Thompson
District 106, D
Pro Environment Vote
James H. Tobin, Jr.
District 126, R
Anti Environment Vote
David L. Tobin
District 39, R
Anti Environment Vote
A. David Trahan
District 59, R
Anti Environment Vote
Joanne T. Twomey
District 19, D
Pro Environment Vote
Ronald E. Usher
District 28, D
Absent
Michael A. Vaughan
District 85, R
Anti Environment Vote
William R. Walcott
District 87, D
Pro Environment Vote
Thomas R. Watson
District 54, D
Anti Environment Vote
Walter A. Wheeler, Sr.
District 1, D
Anti Environment Vote
Richard G. Woodbury
District 44, U
Anti Environment Vote
Raymond Wotton
District 143, D
Anti Environment Vote
Florence T. Young
District 148, R
Anti Environment Vote